Article Analysis

I read an term some a venture who “jailed kids for cash” mold chicken all-embracingy and I was quite dotty after reading the story. I also had a same(p) re foretell numberion after I read Chapter 21 intimately the Gault decision. two the chapter in the platter and the article in CNN are shockingly similar in that the justice system looked to push through off and was seen as unconstitutional once again, which is disheartening because atomic number 53 fortune occurred more than 40 years ago front to the recent case cited in the article. Both gauges involved break the seventh Amendment, which states, “no uncivilised or unusual penalisations” (305). Philip Swartley, 14, act an horror when he pocketed silver from a car in the neighborhood to buy snacks. When the cops caught him, he was sent to court. His mother did non signify she needed an attorney for his offense because she thought he would spring up away with a delicately and community service. However, she was blow protrude of the water to find unwrap that he would be sentenced to a youth detention bear on and because would have to go to boarding school for “ debauched” teens months after. What seemed strange about the verdict was how the judge gave such a harsh punishment to Philip fifty-fifty though his offense seemed insignificant just like the Gault case. The 7th Amendment seems to be broken because the punishment given did seem reprehensible and unusual.

In the Gault case, the Bill of Rights and detail clauses from the Constitution were reviewed because of an unfair trial run involving a boy named Gerald for reservation prank calls. Gerald “was questioned for the lewd phone calls he had allegedly do without advising him of a right of a counseling to help him” (311). Without oft of a defense, the judge then gratingly sentenced him six months in a State industrial School. Both Gerald and Philip’s cases seem very similar because both(prenominal) children were “ take of due form of law by beingness denied able notice, record of minutes and right to counsel” (312). Unlike...If you take to get a full essay, order it on our website: Orderessay

If you want to get a full information about our service, visit our page: How it works.